Click here to see last month's survey.

In Option 2, I like the way the planters create a bit of visual isolation/protection to the porch, which will probably result in higher use of the porch as a place to hang-out. I like the integration of the window pattern next to the door with the windows in that garage door, provided by Option 2. I generally do not like "craftsman" style columns, such as those on the front of the home in Option 1, when they are applied to a non-craftsman style home. For that look to work, I believe a lot more would have to be done to the home to integrate it to the new columns. I like the relatively fresh look of the entry in Option 2. The change in texture/pattern/color of the siding material in Option 2 helps reduce the mass of the two story area; this applies to the darker color of the fireplace as well. Although further information might cause me to change my mind, I believe the window arrangement in Option 2 would allow more light into the entry/core of the home (I'm assuming there is a staircase just beyond the entry).  Since I am biased towards natural lighting, I think I would lean away from the shading over the entry provided by Option 1. Although Option 2 is more contemporary than Option 1, it feels fairly restrained (not too modern) and should not clash with surrounding homes (assuming there are surrounding homes) of similar style to the original. In conclusion, both suggestions are an improvement over the original, as they both formalize the entry of the home, which I am assuming was one of the design goals of the process.  Both designs do invite you more towards the front door, and create a more welcoming feel to the home.”